The rest of this article describes what I do. I can't authorize you to do it this way. In fact, I'll tell you again right now that this is not authorized by Canon and any damage you do to your camera is your responsibility.You've been warned!Read the additional warnings at the end of this page too!If you have one of the newer cameras with anti-dust features or if you have a 5D, REALLY read those warnings carefully!
Many fine tools are available to clean your DSLR's sensor filter. Most of these involve the use of a swab of some sort which has a flat profile. The swab is moistened with a small amount of Methanol and is then drawn across the sensor carefully in one pass to wipe the dust off and collect it. These systems work very well from all of the reports I've read.
Another common method is to use a brush of some sort to brush the dust away. The brushes are often pre-charged with static electricity to make them more attractive to the dust than the sensor filter so that the brush will collect the dust rather than simply push it around. Again, from reports I've read, these brush methods work fine too.
But I wanted something easier to use and less expensive so I did the unthinkable and tried plain old generic cotton swabs. How horrifying!
Those can't work. They aren't high tech. They don't cost enough. It's just too darn easy!
Well, I'm sure these other methods have advantages. And they're well tested and loved by many. So I'm sure they're just great.
But the actual thing touching the sensor filter with any of these other methods is, in every case, something at least as "hard" as cotton.
In the case of the various swabs, the material is usually cellulose. They are a highly refined paper. Cotton is another form of cellulose, and is often regarded as being softer than paper products. Hmmm, that seems OK.
So where is the danger with any of these methods?
Abrasives.
That's what you need to beware of. If you use any of these "touching the sensor" methods, and you happen to have a particle of hard grit (sand or dirt) on the sensor, you run the risk of forcing that grit against the filter and dragging it across it. That would surely scratch the filter. It wouldn't matter what your swab was made of, or even if you were using a brush. If you drag a particle of hard, sharp grit across the sensor filter, you may scratch it.
So regardless of what you use as a swab, your enemy is grit. This is why it's very good practice to pre-clean your sensor carefully with the blower before using any "touching the sensor" method. Always try the blower first. Only move on to any of these swabbing or brushing methods if you've already blown the sensor filter off well and tested to be sure the swabbing/brushing is required.
I buy generic cotton swabs at the local drug store and I keep them in sealed zip-top plastic bags containing about 20 swabs each. That way, I can keep them clean and if I think a bag of them may have gotten contaminated, I just throw the whole bag away. These things are cheap. There is no sense risking the use of a contaminated swab when they cost a half a cent apiece!
And on the subject of contamination of the swabs: When you grab a swab out of the bag, decide which end you'll be using to do the swabbing, and which end will be in your hand. You don't want to touch the end that you'll be using for the swabbing because your skin's oils and dead cells, etc., will contaminate the swab and end up smearing your sensor filter.
Keep it clean.
One more thing about the swabs:
I have found that these generic swabs from the local drug store work better than the "brand name" swabs or the special "high-quality" swabs often sold for delicate cleaning operations. The reason is that the generic swabs' heads are wound looser. The fancy swabs often have their heads wound very tight. This may reduce fiber shedding, but it also means that the tip of the swab is small and tight. The looser-wound generic swabs cover more area in a pass than the tight, hard ones do. This makes it easier to cover the area quickly in less passes and it allows the end of the swab to mash down with very little force applied. The loose swabs get into corners better too.
So while it might be tempting to use the very high quality individually packaged swabs because they should be cleaner, etc., it has been my experience that they don't work as well because they are not as compliant. So the best swabs I've found are the generic ones from the drug store. I suspect that there can be a lot of variation from brand to brand. Try a few different brands and find one that works for you. You want a swab tip that is soft and fluffy not hard and tight. You'll be mopping the sensor filter. Imagine mopping a floor with the end of a stick - wouldn't work very well, would it? You want the mop head to cover some surface area without needing to apply a lot of force :)
Also:
It is possible to wrap a Pec Pad around a cotton swab to make a handy swabbing tool too. So if you'd rather have a Pec Pad in contact with your sensor filter, that's an option. But I've had good luck with the raw swabs so take that all for what it's worth.
OK, OK. We're ready to swab, already.First, I assume that your camera is at normal room temperature of around 20 degrees C (68 degrees F).
It's nice to have a good, bright lamp to work under. I like those swing-arm lamps because you can position them for good viewing. But this isn't completely necessary.
Take the lens off of your camera. Set it aside.
Take out a swab or two and set them down on a clean surface remembering which ends are the "clean" ends.
Now, I'm right-handed so I'll describe this as if you were too. If you're a leftie, just use the other hands. No problem.
Put the camera into the sensor clean mode and turn it up so that you can see the sensor. Of course, you're actually looking through the clear filter, and that filter is what you'll be cleaning, but you get the idea.
Hold the camera in your left hand so that the opening is facing up and you can see into it nice and easy.
If you get the camera and the light just right, you can see the whole surface of the filter, and you can rock the camera around to get the glare from the light to reflect off of that surface. That makes it easy to look for dust, smudges, and other stuff.
You won't be able to see the dust, usually. If it's a whopper, or a piece of lint, you might, but generally, by the time you've blown the camera out a few times, you've gotten rid of anything large enough for you to see. But check it out anyhow! If you see anything that looks like it could be a piece of hard grit on there, you need to think about how to get it knocked and blown off of there before you do the swabbing.
You can poke at it gently with a clean swab and see if it'll move and then blow it off. (Pitch the swab and get a clean one now).
OK, everything looks good? You're ready to swab.
Pick up one of the swabs in your right hand being careful not to touch the "business end" of it.
Hold the camera up and gently breathe (once again, do not blow, sneeze, cough, or wheeze - just breathe out slowly with your mouth fairly wide open) into the body. You will see a fog of condensed moisture form on the sensor filter.
That fog is actually condensed water. By definition, it is distilled water. And further, it's been fractionally distilled because the temperature of the inside of your lungs is only a few tens of degrees warmer than the surface onto which the water condensed.
Thus, this is extremely pure water. A friend of mine who is a chemist pointed out to me that there will also be other gas components of your breath which will end up dissolved into that water too. One main component of note is carbon dioxide. That CO2 will form carbonic acid in this water.
Those acid ions will make the distilled water (a good insulator) into a reasonable conductor. Thus, this slightly acidified water will work well to equalize and dissipate the surface charge of the filter with respect to any dust that is on it. This will make it easier for the swab to remove the dust from the filter.
Canon 20D camera sensor with its filter "fogged" over with condensed breath.
With the filter fogged as shown, you're ready to swab. You've got just the right amount of water to do the job. It won't be so much that you are in any danger of having it run in anywhere yet there is enough there to let you "mop up" the dust.
This photo doesn't show the ideal pattern for swabbing the sensor because I had to take these shots with an uncooperative P&S camera in one hand and the swab in the other while holding the shutter button at half-press after trying to lock the focus..... Well, you get the idea.
So this photo just shows how the condensation is picked up by the swab as you rub it gently over the surface of the filter.
In actual practice, I use a "raster" pattern to scan over the whole surface and then I run the swab around the edges a few "laps" to get the dust that likes to hide in the corners and along the edges.
I don't use much pressure, and I don't need to because unlike with the paper covered spatula technique, I can get the whole surface in due time and I can see where I've been because of the moisture that is being smeared around as I do this.
By looking at the filter as you swab it, you can see where you've been and you can see when the water has been polished off of the surface. When the water is gone, you're done.
Swab removing the water as it cleans the surface.
This shot shows the swab against a dry filter. When it's this dry, you don't need or want to continue with the swabbing.
Yeah, the swab has mysteriously moved to my left hand. I'm sorry, just a continuity error there. Again, I'm shooting the other camera one-handed so that's the way it goes. Let's say this one is for the left-handed folks out there.
The filter is dry, so you're done swabbing.
I run the swab back and forth over the sensor in a pattern like this to get the whole surface clean.
I can see where I've been by the patterns left in the water on the surface.
The final step for me is to run the swab around the outside perimeter of the sensor, up against the edges of the "well" that it sits in. I often make a few laps around the perimeter like this since that's where a lot of the dust seems to end up.
One possible swab wiping pattern.
The main thing is to get the whole surface wiped while there is some moisture there to help out. As the moisture is spread around and evaporates, you can see where you've been and see if the surface looks clean. Once the water is gone, and the surface is shiny and free of streaks, you're done.
The whole process takes about ten seconds.
Throw the swab away. If you decide to swab again, you should use a clean swab. Hey, they're ridiculously inexpensive!
The final blow:Now that you've swabbed the whole sensor, you have one final thing to do. Get the bulb blower and again hold the camera so that the lens mount is aimed down. Do another good, vigorous blowing to get any loose fibers that may have shed from the swab and also any crud that may have fallen into the camera while it was aimed upwards. Blast it good!
Now, turn the camera off to take it out of sensor clean mode, and put your lens back on.
You may now test for dust once again.
It may not be perfect at this point, but I'll bet it's pretty darn close. And if it's not, you know just how easy it is to simply do the same thing again. Sometimes it takes a couple of swabbings. That's fine. It's cheap and fast.
As you do this a few times, you'll get very good at it and become more comfortable with the whole process. You don't need to press hard at all because the swab conforms to the corners and the surface. And you can get into all of the edges and corners with ease.
There is one protrusion on the left side of the "sensor well" that is kind of in the way as you swab (on a 20D), but you soon get a feel for where it is and it's no trouble to angle the swab to avoid it so that it doesn't interrupt the smooth motion of the swab.
A nice, gentle, smooth wipe seems to work the best. Bring the swab into contact with the filter just once and keep it in contact for the whole wipe if possible. That seems to get the dust the best.
You'll get a feel for it after a few tries. Don't expect perfection the very first time. But also don't expect this to be difficult or hard to learn.
Other solvents:(Read the warning below concerning new cameras with special anti-dust coatings).
I have gotten oil on my 20D sensor filter before when using a brush to clean it. I must have touched something in the camera that had some lubricant on it and then transferred that lube to the sensor. That sounds nasty, but really it wasn't much of a problem at all. I simply used some alcohol and a swab to remove the oil. Various alcohols are available for this use. The most common one used in the commercial sensor cleaning preparations is methanol. That works fine on the 20D. See below for other bodies.
However, another good, clean source for a cleaning alcohol is to purchase a new bottle of "Everclear" at the liquor store. Everclear is 95% pure grain alcohol (ethanol). It seems to be very pure and free of impurities that would leave a reside. I've used it a number of times when I wanted a less polar solvent than water. For greases and oils, it is reasonably effective.
Again, use it at your risk, and only use clean Everclear from a fresh bottle. You may wish to keep a bottle just for that purpose so that it does not become contaminated.
Use only a very small amount on the tip of the swab. You DO NOT want the swab to have so much that it could drip or run anywhere! That could be a very bad thing indeed! Use the same method as you'd use with the condensed breath. You can see the alcohol left behind by the swab as you move it over the surface. For nasty oil or other residue, you may need to do this several times. Use a fresh swab for each attempt. It's all very cheap.
The bit of residue left behind after the Everclear swabbing can be removed with a followup swabbing with the condensed breath as the final polish.
It has been said on another website about DSLR sensor cleaning that Canon uses a mixture of alcohol and glass cleaner to clean these sensors. I cannot verify that. But this brings up the idea of using various things to clean the sensor filter. My warning about that would be that if you use the wrong solvent, you may damage or remove the special coatings that are on the sensor filter.
Pure water and methanol have been shown to be safe on the 20D, and I have seen no problems using the ethanol from Everclear. That's all I can say about that.
An additional warning!
Anti-Static sensor filters and such....
NEW: As mentioned above, some newer cameras with anti-dust features are reputed to have a tin oxide (or more likely tin-doped indium oxide) coating on the front surface of the sensor filter. The manufacturers of some sensor cleaning solvents have come out with newer solvents made especially for these cameras. I do not know what the new solvents are exactly, but reports I've read say that the MSDS for one such new "Tin Oxide Compatible" solvent is mostly ethanol denatured with some methanol to make it undrinkable.
The fact that they've come out with a new product suggests that they have found some problem with using their other solvent (pure methanol) on these newer cameras. They were recommending the new non-methanol solvent for the Canon 400D, 5D, 1DMkIII, and 40D. Now I see that they've gone back to recommending the methanol solvent on the 5D. I've read of problems with cleaning the 5D. Reports have been seen of the coating on the sensor filter of the 5D flaking off! Speculation was that the 5D simply used it's "hot filter" coating as the front surface. That coating may be extremely fragile.
If I had a 5D, I'd be VERY careful using anything to clean its sensor. They may well be far more delicate than any of the other Canons. We just don't know for sure.
It appears that the new non-methanol solvents are indicated for NEW model Canon cameras with the "anti-dust" features. So be careful when choosing a solvent to try on one of these newer cameras. There must be some reason why people are avoiding methanol.
As for the scratch resistance of these coatings: I do not know. It may be more delicate than what we formerly faced on these filters. I recently got a 40D but have NOT done extensive testing. I've cleaned it twice with the condensed breath and swab method, and it seems to have worked just fine with no ill effects. But I DO NOT have the extensive experience with it that I do have with the 20D. So take that for what it's worth!
Since the manufacturers of several cleaning systems are not telling people to avoid using their methods on these new bodies, I have to believe that they feel that the new sensor filter coating is not overly delicate. Also, a bit of reading about tin-doped indium oxide coatings indicates that these coatings are sometimes used to increase the wear resistance of glass. Thus, one would hope that the coating is harder than glass which would make it less likely to scratch.
But we do not know exactly what this coating actually is, how it is applied, or whether it might be beneath some other coatings which might still be very delicate or which, perhaps, do not stick to it as well as they do to glass. So the whole assembly might be more delecate or more susceptible to damage from solvents and rubbing. I simply do not know!
You really are doing any of this entirely at your own risk, including using the commercially available swabs and solvents!!
One last disclaimer:
This method is not authorized by Canon. According to Canon, you are only allowed to blow your sensor off. Be sure to try that first every time. And if you decide to attempt my method, don't blame me if you damage your camera. I take no responsibility for anything you might do with this information. It works for me, and I've done it hundreds of times on the 20D with no problem. But I have no idea how competent anyone else is and I cannot test it on other cameras so I can't assume any responsibility for your results. This is probably why Canon only authorizes us to use a blower. They cannot know if we'll end up damaging our cameras with some other method so they just leave us with only the blower.
I have read a couple of horror stories of people scratching their camera's sensor filter using the "normal" sensor wiping methods. These reports are infrequent but not unheard of. And I've read about bad experiences with the 5D's coating being totally removed! Any sensor cleaning that involves touching the sensor with anything carries some risk.
Happy shooting everyone! A clean sensor is a happy sensor :)
|